By Esther Claudette Gittens | Editorial credit: KARITING PICAH / Shutterstock.com

The Catholic Church has played a significant role in global history, including during colonial and imperialist expansions that profoundly affected Black and Native American communities. Some critics argue that certain aspects of the Church’s historical actions and doctrines may be reasons why these groups question its role in their cultural and spiritual lives. Below are ten historical points often highlighted by critics.

1. Role in Colonialism and Cultural Erasure

The Catholic Church played a significant role in the colonization of Africa and the Americas. Missionaries often accompanied European colonizers, and their efforts to convert indigenous populations frequently led to the suppression of traditional spiritual practices, languages, and cultural identities. For Native Americans, institutions like the Doctrine of Discovery (endorsed by the papacy in the 15th century) justified the seizure of indigenous lands and the forced assimilation of native populations.

• Citation: Dunbar-Ortiz, Roxanne. An Indigenous Peoples’ History of the United States. Beacon Press, 2014.

2. Participation in Slavery

The Catholic Church, like many Christian institutions, was complicit in the transatlantic slave trade. Some clergy owned enslaved Africans, and papal decrees like the Dum Diversas (1452) sanctioned the enslavement of non-Christians. While the Church eventually condemned slavery, its early support left deep scars in Black communities.

• Citation: Davis, David Brion. The Problem of Slavery in Western Culture. Oxford University Press, 1988.

3. Forced Boarding Schools for Native Americans

Catholic-run boarding schools in the U.S. and Canada, such as those involved in the residential school system, forcibly removed Native American children from their families. These schools sought to “civilize” them by erasing their languages, traditions, and spiritual beliefs, often through abuse and neglect. The recent discovery of unmarked graves at these schools underscores the lasting trauma.

• Citation: Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada. Final Report. 2015.

4. Failure to Support Civil Rights Movements

During critical periods of civil rights struggles, the Catholic Church’s role was often ambiguous or passive. While individual Catholic leaders and groups supported movements like the Civil Rights Movement, the institution as a whole was criticized for its lack of outspoken support, leaving many African Americans feeling alienated.

• Citation: Massingale, Bryan N. Racial Justice and the Catholic Church. Orbis Books, 2010.

5. Doctrine of Superiority

The Church’s historical teaching of non-Christian peoples as “inferior” or “pagan” fostered a hierarchy that justified conquest and subjugation. This attitude was especially harmful to Native Americans and Africans, who were often portrayed as needing salvation through assimilation to European Christian norms.

• Citation: Pagden, Anthony. The Fall of Natural Man: The American Indian and the Origins of Comparative Ethnology. Cambridge University Press, 1982.

6. Resistance to Liberation Theology

Liberation theology, which emerged in Latin America in the mid-20th century, sought to align Catholic teaching with social justice and anti-colonial struggles. It was particularly resonant for oppressed communities, including Black and indigenous groups. However, the Vatican resisted this movement, criticizing its ties to Marxism and silencing its proponents.

• Citation: Berryman, Phillip. Liberation Theology: Essential Facts about the Revolutionary Movement in Latin America and Beyond. Pantheon Books, 1987.

7. Complicity in Racism and Segregation

In the United States, Catholic institutions often mirrored the broader society’s segregationist practices. Black Catholics were frequently relegated to separate parishes and schools. Even today, some argue that racism persists within the Church’s structures.

• Citation: Bennett, Lerone Jr. Before the Mayflower: A History of Black America. Penguin Books, 1982.

8. Marginalization of Traditional Spiritual Practices

The Church’s efforts to convert African and indigenous populations often rejected syncretic practices that combined Christianity with traditional beliefs. Such rejection marginalized the spiritual heritage of these communities and led to a loss of cultural diversity.

• Citation: Mbiti, John S. African Religions and Philosophy. Heinemann, 1969.

9. Sexual Abuse Scandals in Marginalized Communities

The global sexual abuse crisis within the Catholic Church has disproportionately affected vulnerable communities, including Native Americans and African Americans. Many survivors in these communities face additional barriers to justice due to systemic inequalities and historical mistrust of institutions.

• Citation: Berry, Jason, and Gerald Renner. Vows of Silence: The Abuse of Power in the Papacy of John Paul II. Free Press, 2004.

10. Slow Response to Calls for Reparations

Both Black and Native American communities have called for reparations for historical injustices, including those facilitated by the Church. While some dioceses have made efforts to acknowledge past wrongs, critics argue that these efforts fall short of meaningful restitution.

• Citation: Horne, Gerald. The Counter-Revolution of 1776: Slave Resistance and the Origins of the United States of America. NYU Press, 2014.

Conclusion

Criticisms of the Catholic Church by Black and Native American communities often stem from its historical role in systems of oppression, cultural erasure, and marginalization. However, it is essential to note that many individuals within these communities are devout Catholics who find profound meaning and purpose in their faith. Reconciliation and reform within the Church, guided by an acknowledgment of its history and a commitment to social justice, remain crucial for building trust and healing historical wounds.

This analysis is intended to spark dialogue and reflection. The Catholic Church, like any institution, is multifaceted, and its relationship with diverse communities is shaped by both its failures and its efforts at redemption.

  #AfricanSpirituality, #BlackCommunities, #CatholicChurch, #CatholicReform, #ChurchAccountability, #ChurchCriticism, #ChurchReparations, #CivilRightsMovement, #Colonialism, #CulturalAssimilation, #CulturalDiversity, #CulturalErasure, #DoctrineOfDiscovery, #FaithAndJustice, #FaithAndRedemption, #GlobalBrotherhood, #HistoricalOppression, #HistoricalRacism, #HistoricalReflection, #IndigenousCultures, #IndigenousRights, #LiberationTheology, #MarginalizedCommunities, #MoralAccountability, #OppressionLegacy, #RacialJustice, #RacismInReligion, #Reconciliation, #ReligiousHistory, #ReligiousInclusivity, #ReligiousSuperiority, #ReparationsCall, #ResidentialSchools, #SexualAbuseCrisis, #SocialJustice, #SpiritualHeritage, #SyncreticPractices, #TransatlanticSlaveTrade