By Esther Claudette Gittens | Editorial credit: Ron Adar / shutterstock.com 

Mayor Eric Adams, Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, and City Comptroller Brad Lander have each articulated distinct positions on this issue, particularly in the context of collaboration with the Trump administration’s immigration policies.

The intersection of immigration enforcement and municipal governance has become a focal point in New York City, especially concerning the treatment of undocumented immigrants involved in criminal activities. Governor Kathy Hochul, Mayor Eric Adams, Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, and City Comptroller Brad Lander have each articulated distinct positions on this issue, particularly in the context of collaboration with the Trump administration’s immigration policies.

Governor Kathy Hochul’s Position

Last month, Gov. Kathy Hochul stated that New York state would cooperate, to some extent, with federal immigration authorities. While she supports legal immigrants, including asylum-seekers, she emphasized that she would be “the first one” to call Immigration and Customs Enforcement to deport undocumented immigrants who break the law. The governor did not specify any actions the state would take to protect the hundreds of thousands of undocumented immigrants who are not recent asylum seekers. Hochul made a distinction between immigrants with “legal papers” and those who have committed crimes or are known criminals before arriving in the U.S. 

“Someone breaks the law, I’ll be the first one to call up ICE and say, ‘Get them out of here,’” Hochul said when asked how she would respond to Trump’s plans for mass deportations and whether New York would be a sanctuary state under her leadership. “When those are identified, I’ll be the first one to help get rid of them,” she added. “I don’t want them here. I don’t want anybody terrorizing my citizens.”

Mayor Eric Adams’ Position

Mayor Eric Adams has recently indicated a willingness to cooperate with the incoming Trump administration, specifically with Tom Homan, the designated “border czar,” to address concerns about undocumented immigrants committing crimes in New York City. Adams stated, “I am willing to sit down with the Trump administration and have a conversation about how we can work together to deport those who commit violent crimes in our city.” 

This stance represents a shift from previous policies that limited cooperation with federal immigration authorities, reflecting Adams’ prioritization of public safety. He emphasized that the city would not serve as a refuge for violent offenders, regardless of their immigration status. Adams also expressed interest in revisiting local laws that restrict collaboration with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), including the potential reopening of an ICE office on Rikers Island. 

Public Advocate Jumaane Williams’ Position

Public Advocate Jumaane Williams has been a vocal critic of Mayor Adams’ approach, expressing concerns that increased cooperation with federal immigration enforcement could undermine the city’s sanctuary policies and erode trust within immigrant communities. Williams stated, “We must not allow fear to dictate policies that could lead to the unjust targeting of immigrant communities.” 

Williams advocates for maintaining New York City’s status as a sanctuary city, emphasizing the importance of protecting undocumented immigrants from federal enforcement actions that he views as overly aggressive. He argues that local law enforcement should not be involved in federal immigration matters, as this could deter individuals from reporting crimes or cooperating with police due to fear of deportation.

City Comptroller Brad Lander’s Position

City Comptroller Brad Lander has also expressed reservations about Mayor Adams’ willingness to collaborate with the Trump administration on immigration enforcement. Lander warned of potential negative consequences, stating, “We must be cautious of policies that could lead to mass deportations and the disruption of our communities.” 

Lander supports the city’s sanctuary policies and emphasizes the need to protect immigrant communities from federal overreach. He has called for transparency and accountability in any discussions between the city and federal authorities, advocating for policies that uphold the rights and dignity of all residents, regardless of immigration status.

Comparative Analysis

The differing positions of these city officials highlight a complex debate over public safety, immigration enforcement, and community trust.

• Public Safety vs. Community Trust: Mayor Adams emphasizes public safety, advocating for the removal of undocumented immigrants who commit violent crimes. In contrast, Williams and Lander stress the importance of community trust, cautioning that increased cooperation with federal immigration authorities could lead to fear and decreased cooperation with local law enforcement.
• Sanctuary Policies: Adams appears open to revisiting sanctuary policies to facilitate the deportation of violent offenders, while Williams and Lander advocate for maintaining these policies to protect immigrant communities from federal enforcement actions they perceive as unjust.
• Collaboration with Federal Authorities: Adams is willing to engage with the Trump administration to address specific public safety concerns, whereas Williams and Lander are wary of such collaboration, fearing it could lead to broader enforcement actions and mass deportations.

Conclusion

The debate over how to handle undocumented immigrants who commit crimes in New York City reflects broader national discussions on immigration enforcement and sanctuary policies. Mayor Adams’ willingness to collaborate with the Trump administration marks a significant policy shift, prioritizing public safety concerns. In contrast, Public Advocate Williams and Comptroller Lander emphasize the importance of protecting immigrant communities and maintaining trust between these communities and local law enforcement.

As this issue continues to evolve, it will be essential to balance the goals of ensuring public safety, upholding the rights of immigrants, and maintaining the integrity of New York City’s sanctuary policies.

  #GovernorHochul, #ImmigrantRights, #JumaaneWilliams, #mayoradams, #NewYorkCity, #PublicAdvocate, #PublicSafety, #SanctuaryCity, #TrumpAdministration, ICE, Immigration